Final Thoughts
Final thoughts
Written by Ethan Bernard
April 7, 2024
They say all’s fair in love and war. But that doesn’t seem to be the case in steel. Being deemed “unfair” could get you slapped with shiny new Section 232 tariffs these days. Then again, “unfair” implies a judge. And people on opposing sides seldom agree with the judgment. Such seems to be the current case between the US and Mexico.
Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-Ohio) said in a press release on March 15 that “unfair imports keep coming” from Mexico. Legislation was introduced to Congress last month, the “Stop Mexico’s Steel Surge Act.” Whoever decided to name this one decided to get right to the point.
In an SMU Community Chat in March, Barry Zekelman, executive chairman and CEO of Zekelman Industries, weighed in on the issue.
“Adhere to the deal you signed onto, and we’ll be fine,” he said at the time, regarding the USMCA pact, which removed the tariffs on Mexico in 2019.
“But until then, I’m going to fight like a honey badger,” he added.
Unsurprisingly, the Mexican steel industry and trade associations see things differently.
Steel trade group Canacero disputed the characterization of a “surge” back in December.
I was recently at an event in Houston, and a lot of the conversation there centered around whether that introduced legislation would lead to action, or if it was election-year bluster.
Some seem to think tariffs could be imminent, while others think a resolution will be reached and the status quo will prevail.
Actually, there are quite a few topics of importance to the steel industry that are still up in the air.
Another is AHMSA. On Friday, SMU’s Laura Miller reported on an update given by the Mexican steelmaker on its timeline for a restart. (It’s been shuttered since December 2022). We’ve heard it before. Those in the market waiting for a definite, set-in-stone timeline will have to wait a little bit longer.
What about Evraz North America? Crickets seem to be the order of the day on the sale of the steelmaker’s assets in the US and Canada. (Evraz NA has been for sale since August 2022.)
Finally, the sale of U.S. Steel to Nippon. We’ve seen it swing from a foregone conclusion that only needed to be rubber-stamped, to many doubting it will be approved at all. And that’s all in the space of four months.
For the US-Mexico situation, if something concrete does materialize soon, will Mexico retaliate, as they have warned? What will it mean for the nearshoring trend in which North America is viewed as a single “neighborhood”?
More broadly, could this lead to a cascade effect with nations rolling up the drawbridge to imports? Whatever happens, the domestic steel industry has proved pretty nimble in reacting to pandemics, wars, and shifting domestic politics. We’ll see if this year might just put those skills to the test.

Ethan Bernard
Read more from Ethan BernardLatest in Final Thoughts

Final Thoughts
One thing we've learned from our survey here at SMU: When prices are rising, people have a lot to say. You can be assured that with our most recent survey, the comments were coming in fast and furious.

Final Thoughts
Before we get whipsawed by the current moment, it’s important to reflect on optimism. Whatever happens, consumers are going to need steel.

Final Thoughts
Remember infrastructure week in Trump 1.0? It became a running joke. Because it was almost always derailed by whatever the scandal of the day was. In Trump 2.0, we've got tariff week. And unlike infrastructure week, tariff week is no joke.

Final Thoughts
That’s not to say Section 232 shouldn’t be tightened up. Or that certain trade practices – even among our traditional allies – weren’t problematic. But when it comes to the reboot of Section 232, I do wonder whether there will be some unintended consequences.

Final Thoughts
As February comes to a close this week, the scrap markets are poised for another – and perhaps more extreme – move upward in March. March is usually a month when scrap prices relent as winter’s impediments subside. That’s not the case this year. And this time, the driver of prices will be increased demand from mills along with restricted flows over the last two months.