Environment and Energy
SMA: US steelmakers deserve credit for leading decarbonization charge
Written by Philip Bell
March 1, 2024
When it comes to finding ways to reduce emissions in steel manufacturing, we are in the all-of-the-above camp. Hydrogen, carbon capture and storage, renewable energy, nuclear power, direct-reduced iron (DRI) — all have shown promise. Some, such as on-site solar power, are already a significant part of day-to-day operations at mills operated by members of the Steel Manufacturers Association (SMA). Others are not yet ready for widespread commercial use but could get there soon. In time, breakthrough clean technologies could revolutionize steelmaking.
What we can say for sure is that the American steel industry’s emissions profile is the envy of the world, owing largely to the scrap-based steelmaking that makes up nearly three-fourths of US capacity. On average, an electric-arc furnace (EAF) produces 75% fewer carbon emissions than the extractive, coal-intensive process that integrated steelmakers use. American steel producers are between 75% and 320% more carbon efficient than global producers, depending on the product category, according to the Climate Leadership Council.
Investment in EAF, DRI and other clean steel processes is growing. Between 2021 and 2025, SMA members will have invested $18 billion of their own capital in new or expanded low-emissions operations. Each new project seems to improve on the efficiency of the last one, ensuring that American steelmaking gets cleaner all the time. For instance, one SMA member, SSAB Americas, is already making tens of thousands of tons of SSAB Zero steel plate, which it produces in Iowa, with no carbon emissions per ton.
That’s why we have been surprised in recent days to encounter claims that the United States lags Europe in pursuit of low-carbon-emissions steel manufacturing. Nothing could be further from the truth.
Canada, Germany, the United Kingdom, and other countries are subsidizing a transition to EAF and other low-emissions production at the expense of blast furnaces and basic oxygen furnaces. Altogether, European governments in 2023 committed to invest 8.7 billion euros to make their steel industries look more like ours, according to the GMK Center, a Ukrainian consulting firm.
Why does it matter who is leading the pack? Because current climate and trade rules do not give American steel producers credit for their cleaner operations. And the idea that they trail European companies in pursuit of low emissions makes it harder for them to get fair treatment when it comes to climate and trade.
Integrated steelmakers around the world could make huge cuts to carbon emissions by replacing their blast furnaces and basic oxygen furnaces with EAFs and other low-emission production methods. Instead, many have announced plans to reline their coal-intensive furnaces and use them for decades to come.
To be sure, some are banking on heavily subsidized projects using technologies that are not yet commercially viable. We respect their pursuit of lower emissions, and we wish them success. After all, everyone benefits from emissions reduction.
But make no mistake: American steel producers are leading the charge toward decarbonization. Let’s make sure they get the credit they deserve.
Philip Bell
Read more from Philip BellLatest in Environment and Energy
November energy market update
In this Premium analysis we cover North American oil and natural gas prices, drilling rig activity, and crude oil stock levels. Trends in energy prices and rig counts are an advance indicator of demand for oil country tubular goods (OCTG), line pipe and other steel products.
SMU Spotlight: CRU’s Paul Butterworth talks EAFs, CBAM, and decarbonization
Last month I traveled to Sweden to the CRU Steel Decarbonisation Summit in Stockholm. I wanted to see if the European take on decarbonization was broadly different from what we are talking about here in the US.
SSAB OK’d for $139M from European Commission for decarb
Sweden’s SSAB has been awarded €128 million by the European Commission for the steelmaker’s efforts at decarbonization.
GSCC introduces label for new emissions target
The Global Steel Climate Council (GSCC) has taken a step forward in standardizing the decarbonization process with the publishing of its labeling for a certified science-based emissions target.
DOE set to measure GHG intensity of industrial products, including steel
The US Department of Energy (DOE) is launching a pilot project to measure the greenhouse gas (GHG) intensity of certain energy-intensive industrial products, including steel.