Environment and Energy
SMA Study Conducted by CRU Finds US EAFs Emit 75% Less Carbon
Written by Michael Cowden
July 25, 2022
Steel made by US electric arc furnace (EAF) producers emits 75% less carbon than steel produced by traditional blast furnace-based production.
That’s according to an independent study conducted by Steel Market Update parent company CRU Group for the Steel Manufacturers Association (SMA). The results of that study were released today.
Washington, D.C.-based SMA represents the US EAF steel industry, which accounts for 70% of domestic production. The groups said the study marked an important milestone in objectively measuring greenhouse gas emissions from steel producers.
“Something that can’t be measured can’t be managed, and our new study conclusively measures and validates how using recycled scrap-based EAF technology is the most sustainable means of producing steel today,” SMA president Philip Bell said in a statement.
“There is a lot of inaccurate and misleading information about steelmaking, and we believe this independent study will help further our efforts to achieve a low carbon future,” he added.
The results were also cheered by Steel Dynamics Inc. (SDI) co-founder, chairman and CEO Mark Millett, who is also chairman of the SMA.
“Sustainability has become one of the most important issues in business today, and the steelmaking industry has long faced the challenge of being incorrectly perceived as one that relies on antiquated, inefficient, and highly polluting processes,” Millett said.
“This new study, which has been long overdue, raises the bar for the way we validate our progress in this area,” he said.
Blast furnace-based steel production accounts for 70% of global steel output. Blast furnaces combine iron ore and coal to produce liquid iron. EAF steelmaking, which accounts for nearly 2/3 of US steel output, uses electricity and primarily ferrous scrap to obtain liquid metal. The CRU study concluded that the EAF route emits 78% less carbon at the crude steelmaking level and 74% less at the hot-rolled steel level.
Another key finding was that the carbon footprint for slab rerollers that use imported slab is higher than most US blast furnace producers and significantly higher than all EAF-based flat-rolled steelmakers.
“To ensure the highest level of objectivity and prevent any potential conflicts of interest, the SMA completely entrusted CRU with the management of this project to allow us to research, collect, and analyze data from a wide range of steelmakers to produce the most accurate and comprehensive report possible,” CRU North America president John Ball said.
“Our partnership serves as a model for the way that similar industry organizations can strengthen the integrity of their data by joining forces with a trusted partner that can independently and proficiently validate data,” he said.
A link to an executive summary of the report is here.
By Michael Cowden, Michael@SteelMarketUpdate.com
Michael Cowden
Read more from Michael CowdenLatest in Environment and Energy
GSCC introduces label for new emissions target
The Global Steel Climate Council (GSCC) has taken a step forward in standardizing the decarbonization process with the publishing of its labeling for a certified science-based emissions target.
DOE set to measure GHG intensity of industrial products, including steel
The US Department of Energy (DOE) is launching a pilot project to measure the greenhouse gas (GHG) intensity of certain energy-intensive industrial products, including steel.
Final thoughts
Whether it’s the twists and turns of the presidential election, the U.S. Steel deal, or just what’s happening with the movement of steel pricing, there has been no shortage of stories for us to cover.
Price on trade: Evaluating potential approaches to emissions policy and border measures
The only way to achieve net zero goals worldwide is to significantly reduce the greenhouse gas emissions of the global steel industry. And emissions standards can play a key role in encouraging (or discouraging) steel decarbonization. In that spirit, earlier this year, the Biden administration established a climate and trade task force, aimed at a promoting “a global trading system that slashes pollution, creates a fair and level playing field, protects against carbon dumping, {and} supports good manufacturing jobs and economic opportunity.” These are ambitious and laudable goals. Across sectors, the United States has a significant carbon advantage over many of its economic competitors. This is certainly true in the steel industry, where American manufacturers are among the lowest emitting in the world. In other words, when it comes to steel, climate-focused trade policy can go hand-in-hand with US competitiveness.
CRU Insight: Decarbonization will reshape global steel trade flow
This CRU Insight explores how decarbonization will play a significant role in redefining steel trade patterns by shifting regional competitiveness and increasing steel demand needs.