Ferrous Scrap
Miller on Scrap: Optimism in market as we kick off new year?
Written by Stephen Miller
January 2, 2025
The ferrous scrap markets start the year off in a battered condition after a real drubbing in 2024. There is optimism, but this was felt at times last year, only to succumb to the reality of weak demand and lower steel production.
Will this change in 2025 as many steel industry trade groups and some national economists are predicting? Or will the similar patterns continue into Q1’25? SMU has contacted industry insiders in the scrap trade to learn what they are seeing.
North Central/Great Lakes
One executive in the North Central/Great Lakes region said, “I’ve been pessimistic during the last year and have been right. I want to be optimistic now.”
However, he said he still doesn’t see the numbers adding up to a level where the scrap markets can see appreciable improvement.
A quick look around his area doesn’t reveal an increase in buying levels, as steel prices have not increased and the melt rates are still static to down.
Another hurdle for the Chicago district is the lock closing on the Illinois River. The flow of barges going south is limited and will shut off in late January. This will keep scrap from flowing to the mills along the Lower Mississippi River and increase the amount available for Chicago area-based buyers during most of Q1’25.
South
Traveling to the South, an executive there believes there is no January upside in the region, but “no downside, either.”
Most scrap buyers are still on holiday until next week. There should be more information available then, he added. He was unsure about the restricted scrap flows from Chicago caused by the Illinois River lock closing affecting prices in the region.
Keeping on track
It may be a little too early to get a reliable handle on what scrap prices will do as we begin the new year. SMU will follow up as more information becomes available on domestic activity.
Stephen Miller
Read more from Stephen MillerLatest in Ferrous Scrap
Miller on Scrap: Export prices starting to play catch up
Domestic shredded scrap has experienced a renaissance in pricing since January. And that increase had caused traditional exporters to ship their material to domestic users instead of overseas. But with recent changes, this cycle may end with the resurgence of export demand and continued foreign exchange fluctuations.
Ferrous scrap markets react to tariff reprieves
The situation on ferrous scrap has cleared up with the pause of the implementation of Canadian and Mexican blanket tariffs.
Scrap market chatter this week
In the final week of February, SMU polled steel and scrap executives to gather their insights on the current state of the scrap market as well as future projections.
Miller on Scrap: The ramifications of 25% tariffs on scrap imports from Mexico and Canada
We really don’t know yet what and how severe the impact will be. But we do know ferrous scrap will become more expensive in the US. And it will be less expensive for Canadian mills. The larger consequences will be felt on the Canadian front. Even so, in the Southwest, the tariffs on Mexico will lower prices for Mexican scrap and might limit normal flows across the border.
Op-Ed: Trump tariffs would devastate Canadian recyclers, and hurt the US too
These tariffs would significantly increase costs for American manufacturers that rely on Canadian metals. They would also disrupt supply chains and weaken economic ties that have benefited both nations for decades.