Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
Written by Ethan Bernard
November 17, 2024
At this point in the game I think what we can say about Nippon Steel’s proposed buy of Pittsburgh-based U.S. Steel is that it will go through, it won’t go through, or the outcome will be something new and completely unanticipated. Then again, I’m probably still missing a few options. Perhaps not entirely unexpected, suing the US government has been added to the expanding possibilities to this nearly $15-billion transaction first proposed nearly a year ago. And it seems the man behind that statement seldom issues idle threats.
“If this falls through without a legitimate reason or due process, we will naturally consider suing the US government.”
– Nippon Steel Chairman and CEO Eiji Hashimoto
“The Monster”
Those were the words of Nippon’s Representative Director, Chairman, and CEO Eiji Hashimoto. He recently conducted an interview (Nov. 12) with Bunshun, one of the most influential publications in Japan. Even in translation, it is clear he doesn’t shy away from controversial topics, and doesn’t mince words. The article says he is often known as “the monster” and epitomizes the “Kyushu male spirit.” Also, more relevantly, he has been front and center in the Japanese steelmaker’s attempt to acquire USS.
Betting the company
So, what were the stakes for Nippon at the outset of this process?
“Internally, it was called a ‘bet-the-company deal,’” Hashimoto told Bunshun.
His stated goal, according to the article, was for Nippon to possess the capability to produce 100 million tons of global steel crude production. The USS deal would bring the company closer to that.
CFIUS review faces hard December deadline
The final hurdle remaining is the US Committee on Foreign Investment (CFIUS) review, which was extended in September.
“The review will come out by the end of December. CFIUS has already extended it twice, but it expires at the end of December. A third extension doesn’t happen,” Hashimoto said.
“One way or the other, we’ll have a definitive answer by the end of December,” he added.
That would put the fate of the deal in hands of the Biden administration and not in those of President-elect Donald Trump, who won’t be inaugurated until Jan. 20. (Unless, of course, there is another surprise in a year already full of them.)
Asked if things were moving in a positive direction, Hashimoto wasn’t all that forthcoming. He was also asked if hiring former US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo (who served in Trump’s first administration) as an adviser had a positive effect on the progression of the deal.
“I can’t talk about that either! We’re betting the company’s future and the future of 100,000 employees, risking our lives to fight this 2-trillion-plus yen battle! You think we’d just spill the beans about our strategy?!” Hashimoto exclaimed to Bunshun.
Still, on the legal front in this country, Hashimoto was adamant that US “laws stipulate the procedures.”
He noted that “America decided on these procedures themselves. If the decision is made in accordance with proper procedures, it can’t be helped. But if they reach the wrong conclusion without following legitimate procedures, we’re prepared to sue. That’s all!”
Mori visits the USW
An article from Bloomberg from Nov. 14 said Nippon Vice Chairman and EVP Takahiro Mori was set to visit union workers here in the US this upcoming week.
Recall that the United Steelworkers (USW) union remains stridently opposed to the deal. The union prefers the previous suitor, Cleveland-Cliffs.
The USW issued a joint statement on Nov. 14 from Mike Millsap, USW District 7 director and chairman of the union’s negotiating committee, and from USW International President David McCall.
The union said about Mori (not mincing words, either):
“Let’s be clear about Mori’s true intentions: He wants to turn us against each other. He wants to break our solidarity because, like USS (President and) CEO David Burritt and other top management, he understands the strength we wield when we’re united. His goal – his only goal – is to close the transaction, not preserve our industry or our jobs.”
We’ll be there to report what happens, if there are any fireworks, or if the can somehow gets kicked down the road yet again.
Ethan Bernard
Read more from Ethan BernardLatest in Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
It's that time of year again. You know, that time when people wonder if those things are drones in New Jersey or if the aliens are ready to come onto the stage just in time for Inauguration Day. What will that do for steel price volatility? In any case, the SMU team finds itself in Pittsburgh this week.
Final Thoughts
The Community Chat last Wednesday with ITR economist Taylor St. Germain is worth listening to if you couldn’t tune in live. You can find the replay and Taylor’s slide deck here. You can also find SMU reporter Stephanie Ritenbaugh’s writeup of the webinar here. Taylor is Alan Beaulieu’s protégé at ITR. Many of you know Alan from his talks at SMU Steel Summit. I found Taylor’s analysis just as insightful as Alan’s.
Final Thoughts
Cracks have formed in what has been presented as the Biden administration’s united front against Nippon Steel’s play for U.S. Steel. A report from the Financial Times said parts of the administration are at odds on the deal.
Final Thoughts
It’s been another week of torrid speculation when it comes Trump and tariffs. And another week of mostly flat price movement when it comes to steel sheet and plate. As far as Trump and tariffs go, I think I might have lost track. We've potentially got 10% blanket tariffs on imports from China, 25% tariffs on imports from Canada and Mexico, 100% tariffs on the BRICs, and 200% on Caterpillar. Canada might be the 51st state. Mexico could be the 52nd state. But all can be resolved if you stop by Mar-a-Lago and kiss the ring?
Final Thoughts
Never have I been more certain in declaring that those in the steel industry are less certain now than they thought they’d be at this point before the election.