Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
Written by Ethan Bernard
October 6, 2024
Surprise, surprise. Forget Halloween; the trend this October is all around the unexpected. Known as the “October Surprise,” you never know what is in store for you in the month before a US presidential election. Still, if we pull the dial back date-wise a little bit, a familiar theme has been added to the mix: Kick the can.
Let’s agree to disagree
You may remember this from such hits as The Global Arrangement on Sustainable Steel and Aluminum. The US and EU had a deadline of Oct. 31, 2023. One particular sticking point was the carbon border adjustment mechanism (CBAM) that goes into effect in Europe next year. It’s widely viewed as a non-starter in the US. What would happen? Who would bend?
Turns out no one. A compromise never came. Both sides merely extended their existing trade arrangements for 15 months. One thing of note for those expert in math calculations: 15 months after Oct. 31, 2023… is after the US presidential election.
Play suspended
Nippon Steel’s play for Pittsburgh-based U.S. Steel was first announced last December. Most people thought of it as a sure thing; at least, that was the general consensus. A US ally that already had investments here and a big pocketbook. It just made sense. What could go wrong?
Cleveland-Cliffs and the United Steelworkers (USW) union were against the deal almost from the start. Soon, notable politicians piled on. And then, current and former presidents (Joe Biden and Donald Trump, respectively) joined the fray. And when Biden said he wouldn’t run for re-election, Democratic nominee and current Vice President Kamala Harris said she opposed the buy.
The tension mounted. It seemed like it was fourth and goal, and the crowd was on its feet. At least we were here at SMU. How would it affect the country when people went to the polls?
Well, in this case, the decision was punted. Last month, it was reported that no decision would come before the election.
Strike out
We all remember United Auto Workers (UAW) President Shawn Fain’s colorful language during the union’s strike last year. Apparently, he wasn’t fond of billionaires. International Longshoremen’s Association (ILA) President Harold J. Daggett took a look at Fain’s playbook and said: Hold my beer.
The ILA and the United States Maritime Alliance (USMX) were locked in contract negotiations that affected thousands of workers along the East and Gulf Coasts. The deadline was Oct. 1.
In an interview in September, Daggett promised that a strike would “cripple” the US economy. His language on other matters was colorful as well. And there was an implicit promise of doom. I’m sure the incumbent administration wasn’t thrilled about such an event unfolding in the October surprise time frame.
A reprieve never came, though, and the strike went ahead on Monday. Supply-chain snarls? Would other unions, notably the Teamsters (also fond of colorful language), join in?
And then the strike ended on Thursday. That is, a tentative agreement was reached to extend the current contract until Jan. 15.
While that’s after the election, keep in mind that Inauguration Day is Jan. 20. I’m sure everything will be fine.
So, as this month unfolds, what other surprises could be in store for us? In an effort not to tempt fate, perhaps it’s best not to speculate. Still, let’s just hope the ultimate kick the can doesn’t take place.
I mean, they can’t suspend the election until after the election. Good logic must always prevail. Until Nov. 5, though, we’ll just be keeping an especially close eye on things, and carrying a rabbit’s foot.
Ethan Bernard
Read more from Ethan BernardLatest in Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
It's that time of year again. You know, that time when people wonder if those things are drones in New Jersey or if the aliens are ready to come onto the stage just in time for Inauguration Day. What will that do for steel price volatility? In any case, the SMU team finds itself in Pittsburgh this week.
Final Thoughts
The Community Chat last Wednesday with ITR economist Taylor St. Germain is worth listening to if you couldn’t tune in live. You can find the replay and Taylor’s slide deck here. You can also find SMU reporter Stephanie Ritenbaugh’s writeup of the webinar here. Taylor is Alan Beaulieu’s protégé at ITR. Many of you know Alan from his talks at SMU Steel Summit. I found Taylor’s analysis just as insightful as Alan’s.
Final Thoughts
Cracks have formed in what has been presented as the Biden administration’s united front against Nippon Steel’s play for U.S. Steel. A report from the Financial Times said parts of the administration are at odds on the deal.
Final Thoughts
It’s been another week of torrid speculation when it comes Trump and tariffs. And another week of mostly flat price movement when it comes to steel sheet and plate. As far as Trump and tariffs go, I think I might have lost track. We've potentially got 10% blanket tariffs on imports from China, 25% tariffs on imports from Canada and Mexico, 100% tariffs on the BRICs, and 200% on Caterpillar. Canada might be the 51st state. Mexico could be the 52nd state. But all can be resolved if you stop by Mar-a-Lago and kiss the ring?
Final Thoughts
Never have I been more certain in declaring that those in the steel industry are less certain now than they thought they’d be at this point before the election.