Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
Written by John Packard
September 13, 2019
John Packard is on vacation…
Mill executives have been quick to deflect criticism of their plans to spend billions on mill modernizations and upgrades, arguing that the market will be able to absorb the new capacity–but most steel buyers aren’t buying it. Three out of four respondents to Steel Market Update’s market trends questionnaire this week said they believe the 6-8 million tons of new flat rolled capacity announced by the mills will push prices down and perhaps even force some mills to close.
Analysts differ sharply over the impact of the new capacity over the next five years. Some expect it to oversupply the market and create a glut that could force hot rolled steel prices as low as $450 per ton. Others maintain the industry was long overdue for modernization and that the new facilities will displace outdated mills and a large share of foreign imports.
Comments from respondents show mixed sentiments on the subject. Many are concerned about what has been termed a potential “Steelmageddon”:
“There will be short-term pricing pressures.”
“There’s no way to absorb all the new capacity without some effect like lower prices or other supply (imports or domestic) being cut back.”
“Yes, prices will drop, but lots of factors are in play, some we know of and some we may not.”
“Prices will have additional pressure, but unless the equipment is removed, capacity will not be taken down or mills closed.”
“Yes, prices will drop, but the new capacity is long overdue.”
“Nothing is ever in perfect sync. The new capacity will replace some old capacity, but there will be periods of overlap and thus oversupply. I’m more curious about minimills’ future cost position given that availability of high-quality scrap inputs is declining and HBI is not that cost-effective.”
But some industry executives remain skeptical of the doom-and-gloom predictions:
“I would hope the mills have enough business sense not to create that type of [oversupply] situation.”
“Will there be a glut? Not if they take antiquated and obsolete capacity out of the equation.”
“It depends on government protectionist measures that will be put in place if Trump wins again.”
“Protectionism will be ramped up to compensate.”
“It all depends on demand. If the economy stays strong and the tariffs remain intact, I think there is room [for the new capacity].”
On another subject, it’s not too early to reserve your spot at the upcoming SMU Steel 101 in Ontario, Calif., Jan. 7-8. Most SMU workshops sell out well in advance of the event. The program will include a tour of the California Steel Industries mill. Click here for more information.
As always, your business is truly appreciated by all of us here at Steel Market Update.
Tim Triplett, Executive Editor
John Packard
Read more from John PackardLatest in Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
It’s once again A Tale of Two Cities in the steel market. Some are almost euphoric about Trump’s victory. Others, some rather bearish, are more focused on the day-to-day market between now and Inauguration Day on Jan. 20.
Final Thoughts
One of the perhaps unintentional perks of being a trade journalist is the opportunity to travel and cover an array of industry conferences and events. Some I've attended have been at fun locations, like Palm Springs and Tampa, Fla. Others have been in more practical locations, like SMU’s Steel Summit in Atlanta and American Iron and Steel Institute (AISI) and Steel Manufacturers Association (SMA) meetings in Washington, D.C.
Final Thoughts
t this point in the game I think what we can say about Nippon Steel’s proposed buy of Pittsburgh-based U.S. Steel is that it will go through, it won’t go through, or the outcome will be something new and completely unexpected. Then again, I’m probably still missing a few options.
Final Thoughts
President-elect Donald Trump continues to send shockwaves through the political establishment (again). And steel markets and ferrous scrap markets continue to be, well, anything but shocking. As the French writer Jean-Baptiste Alphonse Karr wrote in 1849, "The more things change, the more they stay the same." (I thought the quote might have been Yankees catcher Yogi Berra in 1949. Google taught me something new today.)
Final Thoughts
President-elect Donald Trump will officially retake the White House on Jan. 20. I’ve been getting questions about how his administration’s policies might reshape the steel industry and domestic manufacturing. I covered the tumult and norm busting of Trump's first term: Section 232, Section 301, USMCA - and that's just on the trade policy side of things. It's safe to say that we'll have no shortage of news in 2025 when it comes to trade and tariffs.