Trade Cases
AISI Stands Behind Tariffs as Court Begins Deliberations
Written by Tim Triplett
December 20, 2018
On Wednesday in New York, a three-judge panel on the U.S. Court of International Trade began deliberating a case that will examine the constitutionality of the Section 232 tariffs imposed by President Trump on imports of steel and aluminum in the name of national security. Opponents argue that such tariffs should be subject to congressional review and that the constitution prohibits Congress from delegating its legislative powers to the president.
For the American Iron and Steel Institute, which is a strong supporter of the Trump tariffs, the proper outcome of the case is clear. “We continue to strongly believe this case is without merit and the effort by importers of foreign steel to undermine the Section 232 relief through this case is bound to fail,” said AISI President and CEO Thomas J. Gibson. “Congress acted within its constitutional authority when it authorized the president to take action to adjust imports, when the Secretary of Commerce has determined that such imports threaten to impair the national security.”
AISI, in conjunction with the Steel Manufacturers Association, in September submitted an amicus brief in the lawsuit. The AISI-SMA submission contends “there is binding Supreme Court precedent (Federal Energy Administration v. Algonquin SNG) which establishes that Congress acted within its constitutional authority when it authorized the president to take action to adjust imports, based on the Secretary of Commerce’s determination. The statute sets forth an intelligible principle for the president to follow in carrying out the policy set by Congress.”
The outcome of the case could affect the administration’s plans to extend the tariffs to other imports, such as automobiles and auto parts, which it argues also threaten national security by eroding the nation’s industrial base.
Tim Triplett
Read more from Tim TriplettLatest in Trade Cases
Canadian PM moves to put tighter check on steel imports
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney has announced new measures to limit steel imports into the country.
Canadian agency reverses dumping decision, terminating CORE trade case
The Canada Border Services Agency has terminated a self-initiated dumping investigation of corrosion-resistant steel sheet (CORE) from Turkey.
OCTG producers in Canada take aim at Mexico, US, others
Evraz NA and Welded Tube of Canada have lodged an unfair trade complaint against imports of OCTG, including those from USMCA trading partners Mexico and the US.
Price: Reciprocal tariff changes and potential new tariffs for Brazil, Canada, others
Trade issues do not seem poised to leave the headlines anytime soon. And as recent developments show, the administration’s tariff policy remains ever-changing.
Bessent on Vietnam: 20% tariff stands, Section 232 protections apply
US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told reporters that tariffs for Vietnamese imports to the US are 20% and "specific industries" have trade protections under the Section 232 tariffs.