Trade Cases

Leibowitz on Trade: Update on the Tariff Debate
Written by Tim Triplett
August 7, 2018
Lewis Leibowitz, trade attorney and contributor to Steel Market Update, offers the following commentary on the latest developments in Washington:
News reports abound on U.S. companies that are hurting as a result of the Section 232 tariffs on steel and aluminum and the China Section 301 tariffs.
Today, the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative announced new Section 301 tariffs on Chinese goods imported into the United States. New 25 percent tariffs on $34 billion worth of Chinese imports went into effect on July 6. The new tariffs target $16 billion of additional imports from China. They will be imposed on imports (“entries or withdrawals from warehouse for consumption” to be precise) effective Aug. 23 (16 days from now). Of the 284 tariff lines slated to be taxed, USTR finally determined to apply tariffs to 279 of them. The final list will be released “shortly” by publication in the Federal Register.
The New York Times reported on Monday that U.S. Steel and Nucor, two large domestic steel producers, have objected to hundreds of product exclusion requests. So far, no request that was objected to has been approved by Commerce officials. Domestic mills claim to make the products that U.S. steel and aluminum users claim they cannot get in the U.S. There is clearly a disconnect. I have reviewed a large number of objections; the disconnect seems to center around whether the products are really available or only theoretically available. Good examples of this are the requests to exclude slab imports from the tariffs. In general, domestic steel companies do not supply slabs or other semifinished steel products (ingots, billets, blooms, etc.) to purchasers on the open market. Over the last 30 years or so, entire industries have grown up relying on open-market sources of semifinished steel—rerollers (e.g., Steelscape, California Steel), seamless pipe and tube producers, wire producers and others—who depend on raw materials made by others. Domestic steel producers are not in that market, which has left the field to foreign products. Yet domestic producers state, to quote one objection from Nucor, that “the U.S. steel industry could have supplied 100 percent of 2017 domestic demand for steel slab, with millions of tons of capacity remaining.” Domestic steel companies are urging the Commerce Department to deny exclusion requests in order to create demand for domestically produced semifinished steel. The department has not shown any signs so far of rejecting this argument. In the meantime, the companies that rely on imports find themselves priced out of the market for their products, made with expensive, tariff-laden raw materials. Will domestic steel companies land new customers for semifinished steel before those customers are driven offshore or out of business? There is plenty of room for argument about that.
On Wednesday, Alcoa filed a massive product exclusion request for semifinished aluminum products. As a major aluminum producer, they make their own semifinished products, but they rely heavily on foreign sources for such products because of competitive pressures. There may or may not be objections to these requests by Alcoa. The company mainly wants to import semifinished aluminum from Canada, a country many critics say should be excluded in toto from steel and aluminum tariffs. It is useful to pay attention to this case.
Lewis Leibowitz
The Law Office of Lewis E. Leibowitz
1400 16th Street, N.W.
Suite 350
Washington, D.C. 20036
Phone: (202) 776-1142
Fax: (202) 861-2924
Cell: (202) 250-1551

Tim Triplett
Read more from Tim TriplettLatest in Trade Cases

SMU Survey: Less support seen for Trump tariff policies
Meanwhile, an increasing number think it's too early to say whether the penalties are going to bring more manufacturing to the US.

CRU: USW seeks exclusion from Trump’s tariffs
The union is also urging stronger enforcement against countries such as China which break trade rules, and a coordinated Canada-US strategy to protect union jobs across the North America

Price on trade: A lot happened last week – and it wasn’t all about tariffs
Should foreign investment be allowed to reshape the American steel Industry? Not to be lost in the recent on-again-off-again tariff frenzy, Nippon Steel’s proposed takeover of U.S. Steel has also found itself in President Trump’s crosshairs when it comes to trade and industrial policy. Nippon Steel initially announced its nearly $15-billion bid for U.S. Steel […]

Trump signs executive order aimed at making US shipbuilding ‘great again’
President Trump on Wednesday signed an executive order meant to breathe new life into American shipbuilding and curb Chinese dominance in the sector.

Trump still against selling USS to Japanese firm: Report
Despite ordering a new review of Nippon Steel’s bid for U.S. Steel, President Trump said he is still against selling USS to a Japanese company, according to media reports.