Trade Cases
DOC Affirms Dumping of Washing Machines from China
Written by Sandy Williams
July 21, 2016
The steel intensive washing machine is the subject of an antidumping investigation brought against China by Whirlpool Corporation.
The Department of Commerce issued an affirmative preliminary determination on Wednesday, July 20, 2016, in the AD investigation into imports of large residential washers manufactured by LG and Samsung in China. The DOC also found that critical circumstances exist with respect to Samsung.
In December 2015, Whirlpool petitioned the DOC to stop the dumping of residential washing machines manufactured in China by Samsung and LG. Whirlpool charged that the two competitors were selling washers at less than fair market value and cited a long-term pattern of pricing below cost, causing injury to American manufacturers. The 2015 petition followed a ruling by the DOC in 2013 (also brought by Whirlpool) that Samsung and LG were dumping washers exported to the U.S. from South Korea and Mexico.
In the press release from Whirlpool in December, Marc Bitzer, president and chief operating officer for Whirlpool Corporation said:
“Simply put, beginning in 2013, Samsung and LG replaced their dumped washers from Korea and Mexico with dumped washers from China. Since then, Samsung and LG have blatantly ignored a previous U.S. government order by continuing to dump washers into the United States. At Whirlpool, we know that open, rules-based trade ensures the highest level of innovation and choice for consumers. Our ability to innovate, invest and continue to manufacture here in the U.S. is undermined when foreign competitors willfully defy U.S. government rulings. We have continuously monitored this situation during the past several years and have spent the past several months preparing this petition as the next step in an ongoing effort to prevent this serial dumping.”
Wednesday’s preliminary ruling by the DOC found dumping has occurred by mandatory respondents Nanjing LG-Panda Appliances Co., Ltd. (LG), and Suzhou Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. and Suzhou Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd – Export (collectively, Samsung) at preliminary dumping margins of 49.88 percent and 111.09 percent, respectively. Commerce calculated a preliminary dumping margin of 80.49 percent for all other producers/exporters in China.
Critical circumstances were found to exist in regards to Samsung. Critical circumstances are found when a surge of imports occurs over a relatively short period of time in anticipation of possible AD duties.
“Today’s ruling is an important step forward in an effort to stop serial dumping practices by Samsung and LG and uphold free and fair trade practices,” said Bitzer following the DOC announcement. “At Whirlpool, we know that open, rules-based trade ensures the highest level of innovation and choice for consumers.”
Cash deposits will be collected on the preliminary AD rates by the U.S. Customs and Border Protection. In the case of the critical circumstances, CBP will impose provisional measures retroactively on entries of certain washing machines up to 90 days prior to publication of the preliminary determination in the Federal Register notice.
Case Timeline:
December 2015 – Whirlpool Corporation files antidumping petition
January 2016 – USITC issues unanimous preliminary affirmative vote to continue the antidumping investigation
July, 20, 2016 – DOC issues affirmative preliminary antidumping determination
December 9, 2016 – DOC expected to release its final antidumping determination
January 2017 – USITC expected to release its final determination regarding injury
January 2017 – DOC expected to issue a final order based on Commerce Department’s and U.S. International Trade Commission’s final affirmative determinations
If either Commerce’s or the ITC’s final determination is negative, no AD orders will be issued.
Sandy Williams
Read more from Sandy WilliamsLatest in Trade Cases
Mills allege ‘critical circumstances’ in CORE trade case vs. South Africa, UAE
"Recent activity in the marketplace strongly indicates that these imports are being rushed into the United States in an effort to avoid the imposition of antidumping duties," petitioners said.
European Commission eyes retaliation vs. Trump steel tariffs: Report
The European Commission is looking into making current quotas on steel imports stricter as a countermeasure to President Trump’s recently announced tariffs on steel and aluminum imports to the US, according to an article in Reuters.
Trump could levy tariffs on auto imports in April: Report
President Donald Trump said last week that he could place tariffs on auto imports, according to an article in Politico.
Section 232 tariffs are headed downstream
The Trump administration has revealed the list of derivative steel products being added to the Section 232 tariff list.
Leibowitz: In Trump’s brave new world of tariffs, what will stick and what will courts challenge?
With a chronic trade deficit, the administration will continue to cite more tariffs as necessary. This is in error, as noted above. Yet the base of President Trump’s support does not see it that way. More tariffs are possible. But the only way to reduce the US trade deficit substantially is to close the gap between savings and investment in the United States.