Trade Cases
![](https://www.steelmarketupdate.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/media/k2/items/src/9816dac52420d7b67562baed42e72a43.jpg)
DOC Initiates Circumvention Inquiry on CTL Plate from China
Written by Sandy Williams
February 23, 2016
The Department of Commerce is initiating a circumvention inquiry on imports of cut-to-length steel plate from China following a petition from Nucor and SSAB.
The two steel mills assert that producers, exporters and importers are circumventing duties imposed on CTL by adding alloys, such as boron, titanium and chromium to the product. The Department of Commerce will investigate the addition of such alloys to CTL plate of ASTM grade A36 and A572, originating from China.
Commerce will issue a final determination within 300 days of the date of initiation (February 18, 2016).
Steel Market Update spoke with trade attorney Lewis Leibowitz earlier today about this circumvention inquiry (which is different from a petition under the ENFORCE Act). This is what he had to share with us on the subject:
This is an anti circumvention inquiry (ACI) initiated by Commerce last week…
An ACI is different from a Customs investigation into evasion of an order. Customs (ENFORCE Act) gets involved when the scope of the order is clear and the importer and/or its foreign suppliers simply lie about what is in the shipment. An ACI is a request to Commerce to expand the scope of an order when there are “minor alterations” to a product specifically designed to get around the scope of an order. Commerce has the authority to expand the order to cover such “minor alterations”. That is what we have in the China case you referred to.
There are larger issues here, of course. Anti circumvention proceedings are not so broad as to allow a rewrite of the scope of an order. That is why ACIs are limited to “minor” changes in the products. Petitioners are not very concerned about the problems caused by creating infinitely malleable and expandable orders. But Congress was a bit concerned—as is the WTO.
Over the last ten years or so, several ACIs on carbon steel orders have related to the addition of boron as an alloying element. Apparently, adding boron does not do much to the characteristics of the steel for standard commodity-grade use. CTL plate from China had just such an ACI several years ago. Now, Chinese producers are allegedly adding other elements (e.g., chromium, titanium) that only change the characteristics of the steel if it undergoes heat treatment. The accusation is that the steel is being sold under standard commodity-grade ASTM specs (no heat treatment), but has alloying elements that meet the definition of “alloy” steel rather than “carbon” steel. Petitioners further allege that the cost of adding these elements to the steel is “minor” and that the only motivation for doing so is to circumvent the order.
The case has just been initiated, and will take the better part of a year to sort out. Note that Commerce did not initiate on all the petitioners’ allegations. For one thing, they are concerned about administering the order, so they do not favor any criterion that depends on knowing what’s done with the product after initial importation.
There will be a lot of arguing back and forth about these issues. At the end of the day, if Commerce is convinced that the additional cost is “minor” and that the only motive is circumvention, they would probably expand the scope.
One other point—because of a “history” of circumvention in this case, the ACI is not limited to particular exporters (this is different from the tissue paper case I sent yesterday). All CTL plate from China is covered by the ACI.
![](https://www.steelmarketupdate.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2023/04/sandy-williams.jpeg)
Sandy Williams
Read more from Sandy WilliamsLatest in Trade Cases
![](https://www.steelmarketupdate.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/images/Featured_News_Icons/galvanized_coil.png)
Leibowitz: The consequences of a new barrage of trade cases on coated steel
Domestic steel producers and the United Steelworkers (USW) union filed a barrage of trade cases last week. This is hardly news. Ever since the Commerce Department ruled that Vietnam is still treated as a nonmarket economy (NME) for antidumping purposes, many in the business expected new cases on the product that Vietnam excels at—“corrosion-resistant steel.” Nor is it a surprise that these cases roped in nine countries in addition to Vietnam: Australia, Brazil, Canada, Mexico, the Netherlands, South Africa, Taiwan, Turkey, and the United Arab Emirates. All these countries rank in the top ten exporters of corrosion-resistant steel to the United States. These petitions are a broadside against coated flat-rolled steel imports.
![](https://www.steelmarketupdate.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/images/Featured_News_Icons/investigate.png)
Coated trade case alleges hefty dumping margins
Domestic mills have alleged substantial dumping margins in the trade case targeting imports of corrosion-resistant steel.
![](https://www.steelmarketupdate.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/images/Featured_News_Icons/fist.png)
US mills file sprawling trade case against coated imports from 10 nations
US mills have filed or soon will file a sprawling trade petition against imports of coated flat-rolled steel from 10 countries. The petition seeks anti-dumping margins against Canada, Mexico, Brazil, the Netherlands, Turkey, the United Arab Emirates, Vietnam, Taiwan, Australia, and South Africa. It also seeks countervailing duty margins against Canada, Mexico, Brazil, and Vietnam. That’s according documents dated Sept. 5 and addressed to Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo and International Trade Commission (ITC) Secretary Lisa Barton.
![](https://www.steelmarketupdate.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/media/k2/items/src/cbd2ad03f626e665deb71b2742b25bbb.jpg)
Steel Summit 2024: Trade issues abound ahead of election
Trade is always front and center in an election year. And 2024 is no different. There is no shortage of issues, with questions like the sale of U.S. Steel to Japan’s Nippon Steel, potential cracks in the USMCA, and Chinese overcapacity dominating the headlines. But how do you distinguish between issues that might just last until November, and what are the crucial questions that could affect your business for years to come?
![](https://www.steelmarketupdate.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/images/Featured_News_Icons/fist.png)
US senators urge reduction to S. Korean OCTG quota
https://www.brown.senate.gov/newsroom/press/release/sherrod-brown-casey-fetterman-biden-administration-level-playing-field-american-octg-industry