Steel Markets
AGC Files Suit Over PPP Questionnaire
Written by Sandy Williams
December 10, 2020
The Associated General Contractors of America filed a lawsuit on Wednesday alleging that the Small Business Administration and the Office of Management and Budget secretly crafted an intrusive questionnaire that gathers irrelevant information on business operations to reassess eligibility for Paycheck Protection Program loans.
“The administration has every right, and obligation, to ensure businesses were eligible to apply for and receive the relief loans,” said Stephen E. Sandherr, the AGC’s chief executive officer. “But they do not have the right to use a secretly crafted form to gather unprecedented amounts of proprietary information that has little or nothing to do with the economic uncertainty that led businesses to apply for the loans in the first place.”
AGC is requesting that the court declare the questionnaire arbitrary and capricious, and that the SBA cannot lawfully use the information the form generates to find a company ineligible for a PPP loan or deny a company’s application for forgiveness of its loan.
Businesses that have borrowed an original PPP loan of $2 million or greater are required to fill out and return the questionnaire, Form 3509, within 10 days of receipt from their lender. Failure to do so could result in a determination by SBA of ineligibility and a requirement to pay back the loan.
The nine-page questionnaire asks for details on a company’s financial status including revenue, liquidity, employee compensation, equity securities and foreign ownership status.
The complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court of the District of Columbia, also asserts that the agencies ignored a legally mandated process for developing the questionnaire, thus violating the Paperwork Reduction Act and the Administrative Procedures Act. AGC said the OMB authorized SBA to use the form in “compete secrecy” without releasing it for the usual 60-day public comment period. In order to bypass the normal review process, AGC charges that the agencies arbitrarily declared that the questionnaire required approval on an “emergency” basis and did not constitute a change in the scope of SBA’s prior information collection process.
“The CARES Act (which established the PPP program) only required loan applicants to make a ‘good faith certification that the uncertainty of current economic conditions makes necessary the loan request….’ Instead of asking borrowers how they concluded they faced such uncertainty when applying for their loans, the form attempts to set a means test, a revenue reduction test and a liquidity test that Congress never contemplated, and it focuses on later events that few companies could have predicted when applying,” said AGC.
“Resorting to a secret form that disregards Congressional intent and retroactively changes the criteria for a loan is not due diligence; it is unlawful and needs to stop before employers are irrevocably harmed,” said Sandherr.
Sandy Williams
Read more from Sandy WilliamsLatest in Steel Markets
Steady architecture billings signal improving conditions
The November ABI decreased month over month but was still the third-highest reading of the past two years.
Fitch warns more tariffs will pressure global commodity markets
“New commodity-specific tariffs, mainly on steel and aluminum products, could widen price differentials and divert trade flows,” the credit agency forewarned.
Slowing data center, warehouse planning drives decline in Dodge index
The Dodge Momentum Index (DMI) slid further in November as planning for data centers and warehouses continued to decline.
Latin America’s steel industry grapples with declining demand, rising imports
With climbing imports and falling consumption, the Latin American steel industry has had a challenging 2024, according to an Alacero report.
CRU: Trump tariffs could stimulate steel demand
Now that the dust has settled from the US election, as have the immediate reactions in the equity, bond, and commodity markets, this is a prime opportunity to look at how a second Trump presidency might affect the US steel market.