SMU Data and Models
Steel Mill Negotiations: Buyers Bargaining
Written by Tim Triplett
June 25, 2020
Steel demand is slowly improving as the economy moves on from the coronavirus shutdowns, but the environment remains very competitive, and buyers report that most mills are willing to negotiate on price to win orders of flat rolled steel.
Steel prices have moved up erratically since hot rolled bottomed at $460 per ton in late April. Flat rolled steel prices hit $515 per ton last week but declined this week as supplies continue to exceed orders even with the increasing demand. The benchmark price for hot rolled dipped below the $500 per ton mark for the first time since the third week of May to $490, according to Steel Market Update’s canvass of the market this week. The average price for cold rolled moved down to $665 a ton, while galvanized declined to $660 per ton.
In the hot rolled segment, 82 percent of the steel buyers responding to SMU’s questionnaire this week said the mills are now open to negotiation, while just 18 percent said the mills are standing firm on prices. That’s a 12-point shift from two weeks ago and a 25-point increase from this time last month.
In the cold rolled segment, 69 percent reported the mills willing to talk price, down five points from 74 percent two weeks ago and about the same as last month.
In galvanized, 89 percent reported the mills open to price negotiation this week, up 11 points from 78 percent in SMU’s last canvass of the market. The majority, about 63 percent, have found the mills willing to compromise on Galvalume prices lately as well.
Negotiations have tightened in the plate market, where 55 percent said the mills are still willing to bargain to capture the sale, while 45 percent reported the mills saying no to discounts. That compares to 91 percent who said the mills were talking price two weeks ago.
SMU is keeping its Price Momentum Indicator at Neutral until the dynamic between buyers and sellers becomes clearer.
Note: SMU surveys active steel buyers twice each month to gauge the willingness of their steel suppliers to negotiate pricing. The results reflect current steel demand and changing spot pricing trends. SMU provides our members with a number of ways to interact with current and historical data. To see an interactive history of our Steel Mill Negotiations data (second example below), visit our website here.
Tim Triplett
Read more from Tim TriplettLatest in SMU Data and Models
SMU Survey: Steel Buyers’ Sentiment Indices contrast at year end
Both of our Sentiment Indices remain in positive territory and indicate that steel buyers are optimistic about the success of their businesses.
SMU Survey: Mill lead times contract slightly, remain short
Steel mill production times have seen very little change since September, according to buyers participating in our latest market survey.
SMU Survey: Buyers report mills are slightly less flexible on pricing
Steel buyers of sheet and plate products say mills are still willing to bend on spot pricing this week, though not quite as much as they were two weeks prior, according to our most recent survey data.
December energy market update
Trends in energy prices and active rig counts are leading demand indicators for oil country tubular goods (OCTG), line pipe and other steel products
Apparent steel supply remained near two-year low in October
Referred to as ‘apparent steel supply’, we calculate this volume by combining domestic steel mill shipments with finished US steel imports and deducting total US steel exports.