SMU Data and Models
SMU Market Trends: Most Doubt Price Hike Will Stick
Written by Tim Triplett
October 18, 2018
Will the flat rolled mills be successful in collecting the $40 per ton price increase they announced last week? No, they will not, predict eight out of 10 steel executives who responded to this week’s Steel Market Update Market Trends questionnaire. Only about 20 percent believe the price increase will stick. Following are some insightful comments:
• “Everybody that I talk to thinks this increase was an attempt to shore up pricing. I am just glad I don’t have to place any orders right now.”
• “The increases won’t stick, but prices won’t go down in the short term.”
• “When Ken Iverson was around, they would lower the price when the order book was soft. Today, Nucor announces a price increase to attempt to generate demand? While this may stabilize the market short-term, prices will once again decline in about two weeks.”
• “Demand is down.”
• “It should establish a bottom…”
• “It’s only a line in the sand. The mills are worried there will be a lot of pressure on price negotiation through the end of the year. They are attempting to make a stand!”
• “It will keep the market flat. Buyers on the fence will place orders to avoid the price increase.”
• “There’s no basis for an increase.”
What motivated the mills to announce the price hike? The majority (60 percent) of respondents believe it is an effort to stop the downward spiral that has seen steel prices weaken by $100 per ton since July. Another 10 percent see it as a ploy to entice contract buyers to place orders sooner rather than later. About 3 percent feel the steelmakers need higher prices to recover higher input costs. Yet another 3 percent consider it simple greed on the part of the mills. About 24 percent point to “all of the above” as the motivation.
“This is a typical mill move when the market is moving down,” commented one respondent. “It will stop the price slide and initiate the annual contract process on a stronger footing,” said another. “Mills are in the business to make money, so why not make more profits,” commented one executive. “Greed and stupidity,” asserted another. “The tariffs have given them a blank check to jack prices way up.”
Tim Triplett
Read more from Tim TriplettLatest in SMU Data and Models
SMU Survey: Steel Buyers’ Sentiment Indices contrast at year end
Both of our Sentiment Indices remain in positive territory and indicate that steel buyers are optimistic about the success of their businesses.
SMU Survey: Mill lead times contract slightly, remain short
Steel mill production times have seen very little change since September, according to buyers participating in our latest market survey.
SMU Survey: Buyers report mills are slightly less flexible on pricing
Steel buyers of sheet and plate products say mills are still willing to bend on spot pricing this week, though not quite as much as they were two weeks prior, according to our most recent survey data.
December energy market update
Trends in energy prices and active rig counts are leading demand indicators for oil country tubular goods (OCTG), line pipe and other steel products
Apparent steel supply remained near two-year low in October
Referred to as ‘apparent steel supply’, we calculate this volume by combining domestic steel mill shipments with finished US steel imports and deducting total US steel exports.