SMU Data and Models

Steel Mill Negotiations: Everyone Was Dancing Prior to Price Announcements
Written by Tim Triplett
October 19, 2017
On Monday of this week, Steel Market Update began collecting data for our mid-October flat rolled steel market trends analysis. We invited over 600 companies to participate in our questionnaire. The vast majority of the respondents are either service centers or manufacturing companies. Based on the data collected we found that prior to any of the steel price announcements, the vast majority of buyers and sellers of steel were reporting the steel mills as willing to negotiate hot rolled, cold rolled, galvanized and Galvalume steel pricing.
Steel buyers’ perceptions of their suppliers’ attitudes offer a snapshot of how steel mills are currently handling price negotiations. We will not know if the steel mills will significantly alter their negotiation stances until our next market trends analysis is conducted during the first week of November. We are going to refer to two data collection points from this week’s questionnaire as we look at price negotiations.
Nearly 62 percent of respondents agreed that mill order books are weaker than expected and most suppliers are open to price discussions. The other 38 percent characterized the market as mixed, with some mills flexible on price and others firm. Two weeks ago, the ratio was about 70/30. So, we have picked up a slight increase in the percentage of our respondents reporting “mixed” results. However, zero percent of the respondents reported order books as “firm.” This will be important to watch in the coming weeks as it will impact whether the announced price increases will stick, or fail. Note: More than 90 percent of the responses were made prior to ArcelorMittal announcing a price increase.
By product category, 92 percent of manufacturing and service center respondents saw mills willing to negotiate hot roll orders, down from 95 percent two weeks ago. In cold roll, 87 percent reported prices as negotiable, down from 89 percent in early October. In the Galvalume market, 80 percent reported a willingness among mills to talk price on coated products, down from 89 percent two weeks prior. Galvanized was the exception, increasing to 90 percent from 83 percent.
“They were willing to negotiate until this morning,” commented one service center. “Willingness to negotiate is directly linked to a mill’s lead time right now,” said another service center exec. “Deals are there if you want to make them,” added a trader.
Note: SMU surveys active steel buyers twice each month to gauge the willingness of their steel suppliers to negotiate pricing. The results reflect current steel demand and changing spot pricing trends. SMU provides our members with a number of ways to interact with current and historical data. To see an interactive history of our Steel Mill Negotiations data, visit our website here.

Tim Triplett
Read more from Tim TriplettLatest in SMU Data and Models

SMU Scrap Survey: Current Buyers’ Sentiment flat, Future Sentiment tumbles
SMU's Current Scrap Buyers' Sentiment Index remained flat this month, while the Future Sentiment Index declined.

SMU Survey: Steel mill lead times show diverging trends
Buyers responding to our latest market survey reported that sheet lead times continue to gradually decline from recent highs. Meanwhile, plate lead times increased to levels last seen one year ago.

SMU Survey: Mills unlikely to budge on price, buyers say
Four out of every five steel buyers who responded to our latest market survey say domestic mills are unwilling to negotiate on new order spot pricing. Mills have shown little flexibility on pricing for nearly two months.

SMU’s March at a glance
SMU’s Monthly Review provides a summary of our key steel market metrics for the previous month, with the latest data updated through March 31.

SMU Survey: Steel buyers maintain confident market outlook
SMU’s Buyers’ Sentiment Indices showed mixed movements this week but remain strong, reflecting continued confidence among steel buyers.