Steel Mills
Consolidation Will Strengthen Steel Mills
Written by John Packard
October 19, 2014
Steel Market Update received the following from a member of the financial community regarding consolidation and its impact on the steel industry both short and long term. I am reproducing the email in its entirety and you are welcome to add your comments:
“Hope you are well. Wanted to touch base on your recent steel consolidation commentary. While I understand the need to express some caution regarding the benefits, I am also perplexed by some of your comments. First of all, I think it is necessary to remember the STLD / AKS transactions closed 3 weeks ago. NUE has not yet taken control of the Gallatin mill. MT just took control of TK Alabama 6 months ago. The idea new management teams would have been in a position to show up and immediately change the mill approach to marketing is crazy to me. Just from a practical standpoint, mills typically have different software programs that would slow the process of integrating into a new ownership model. However, I don’t believe that this suggests STLD / AKS will continue to allow those marketing teams to run autonomously potentially at the expense of realized steel prices across the mill’s total tons.
“There is a long history of consolidation in North America delivering significant benefits. The containerboard industry and airlines being the most obvious examples. However, in both cases those benefits were not realized day one. In the case of containerboard it took a whole year after IP bought Temple Inland for the industry to increases prices. Within the subsequent year, the industry realized two prices increases moving containerboard prices up over $100 per ton – while the equities more than doubled. In the case of airlines again it took more than a year for the benefits to translate to earnings – those equities are up 3-4x since then. Again I think it is far too premature to speculate that consolidation in the North American industry steel industry will not be beneficial. In fact I find it very difficult to argue that consolidation could in any way be a negative.
“To that point I fundamentally do not understand the argument that AKS / STLD now have more tons to place and will therefore be more aggressive. The two companies did not add tons to the North American market. Rather they consolidated tons into the hands of fewer players. A steel buyer is no better positioned today from a supply perspective. Rather they have now lost the flexibility to competitively bid steel offers across a broader range of suppliers. STLD and AKS are actually now incented to act in more rational manner as STLD will not want to bid MS tons against Butler nor will AKS want to compete for sales from Dearborn vs. Ashland. This seems like pretty obvious economic theory to me….”
If you would like to add your thoughts you can do so by sending an email to: info@SteelMarketUpdate.com.
SMU Note: AKS = AK Steel, NUE = Nucor, TK = ThyssenKrupp now AM/NS Calvert, STLD = Steel Dynamics, IP = International Paper
John Packard
Read more from John PackardLatest in Steel Mills
AHMSA opens doors to potential buyers as $1.3B asset auction nears
AHMSA is opening its doors to potential buyers to tour its steel plant and mining operations in northern Mexico in preparation for the next stage of its bankruptcy process: the auction of its assets.
USW seeks clarity on USS plans for Granite City Works
The United Steelworkers union has asked U.S. Steel to elaborate on its Granite City Works plans following reports that the steelmaker is ending processing at the facility.
Nucor maintains plate prices, opens October order book
Nucor aims to keep plate prices flat for a seventh straight month with the opening of its October order book.
ArcelorMittal Mexico to import from sister mills as it works to resume DRI production
ArcelorMittal has partially restarted operations at its direct reduction plant in Lazaro Cardenas, Michoacan. An explosion on Aug. 18 rocked the massive steelworks on Mexico’s Pacific coast, impacting production of direct-reduced iron (DRI).
Fall maintenance outages are coming in hot
Labor Day has passed, the sun is starting to set a little earlier each day, and cooler weather has begun to find its way down to many of us across North America. And you know what that means for the steel industry… Fall maintenance outages!