Steel Products Prices North America

CRU Completes Audit of Data Providers

October 17, 2013

The following information was in a press release received by SMU from CRU. We have requested more information from CRU regarding the audit, how it has impacted their data providers and any other pertinent information they were able to gather through the process. We will follow up with another article when we receive information from them. Until then, here is their press release:

The third-party audit of CRU’s weekly US Midwest hot-rolled coil, cold-rolled coil, hot-dipped galvanized coil and plate price indices – the most widely used carbon steel indices in the world – has been completed.

The audit, which was carried out by a Big Four international audit firm selected by CRU, was split into three distinct parts. Firstly, the data providers, who provide actual spot transaction data electronically to CRU, completed a detailed electronic survey. Secondly, a sample of providers, buy-side and sell-side, received an on-site visit to validate their survey responses. The third element of the process involved CRU’s Level 2.0 methodology and its price collection platform being reviewed.

One of the key findings of the audit process stated, “Overall, we noted that the data controls we reviewed designed to support the Price Assessments process and to maintain the integrity of the underlying data at CRU are fairly presented and there are no major gaps.”

On learning of the audit, Peter Whiting, Chairman, President & CEO of PTC Group Holdings Corp. said: “The CRU US Midwest carbon steel price index is very important to our business and we are pleased to see greater transparency in the data collection process that should lead to added confidence in the credibility of the index.”

Glenn Cooney, Head of Operations for CRU Indices, said: “A full report on the results has been distributed to data providers. CRU subscribers can request a summarized version of the report when they log in to their online account.”

Fraser Murdoch, Chief Operating Officer at CRU, said: “Our investment in this audit process, the first of its kind across the commodities index spectrum, signifies CRU’s ongoing commitment to producing the most robust and transparent price indices in the carbon steel market. “

“At a time when some price reporting agencies (PRAs) have been under attack and some are still under investigation, it is crucial that companies like CRU continue to invest in both excellent processes and third party assessments of our work.”